Johny Depp is usually a hottie in his rolls..but in this one..he looked like michael jackson in my oppinion..and that's jsut freaky..but in pirates of the caribean..uh-hem..nvm..uh..gen wilder gets my vote.
I think the point has been misunderstood, but thats cool. I meant more of the actor's portrayal of the character, not necessarily the merits of the two movies because they are very different and separated by time. But I guess it's too closely related to separate the actor from the movie. :)