Well if the guy can pull it off, like Alex Evans or Pete Wentz, then yes. HOTT! But if they don't have to actual look for eyeliner material, then they can't pull it off :]
I can't stand it when guys where make up unless it's to cover acne or for halloween. I think guys should be manly an macho, like the woman below said about the rules of attraction. Nothing about a fem guy is sexy, it defeats the whole purpose of a man, if I wanted a man with make up, I'd mine as well be attracted to women. Long hair is a no go as well. I understand, some punk rockers and just rockers in general where it. It's the look they're going for on stage, but in everyday life, no. Just my opinion as Simon says.
So if he isn't doing it for chicks but doesn't refuses a chick's advances, foes that prove he lied? Is there a number of rejections he's supposed to do before he can be with her?
how can girls think it's hot? kinda relates to the emo/goth/whatever you want to call it style. so to answer your question you have to answer why they like this style? as far as i know the stereotype where's tight clothes, long hair and makeup, all this seems pretty feminine... so... maybe girls are attracted to guys that look a little more like girls? or is it something else? Maybe they are looking for a sensitive guy and they can't really be bothered with finding out the soul of a guy and their true self which takes time so they go and look purely on the outside. maybe they have had bad experiences with people of all other types and want to go with someone like that, but you have to remember that not ALL girls like guys like that, everyone has they're own tastes, being a guy i can't answer the question XD but maybe they like the feminine look, something they can relate too? more sensitive perhaps? who knows! :3