riddles...

i know everyone asks the riddle, if a tree falls in a forest...but no one is around to hear it...does it make a noise? my answer is yes...and i have 2 reasons why...1. to survive, trees need air. its how they live...no air no sound...since they would be dead, and wouldnt be able to fall ( without air,)so when they fall, there WILL be air...and so, there would be a sound. 2. the riddle says no one. so therefore...if you took a friend along (it could even be your dog) so it wouldnt be no one around to hear it, it would be 2. and so, it wouldnt break the rule of the poem.